UNITED NATIONS MISSION OF OBSERVERS

IN TAJIKISTAN (UNMOT)

NEWSLETTER

22 July-3 August 1998, No. 22

THE COLD-BLOODED MURDER OF UNARMED PEACE-KEEPERS

On Monday, 20 July 1998, an UNMOT team comprising of Major Ryszard Szewczyk, Major Adolfo Scharpegge, Yutaka Akino, and Jourajon Mahramov had left their team site in Garm to go on a routine authorised patrol. After they failed to report late that day search teams had been alerted. When dispatched they established the horrifying fact that four UNMOT colleagues had been cowardly ambushed and brutally murdered. Their bodies could only be found after a helicopter search of the area became possible in daylight the following day. Preliminary examination of the bodies proved the brutal nature of the attack. The Special Representative of the Secretary General in Tajikistan, Mr Jan Kubiš, and all the staff at UNMOT were profoundly shocked and enraged. Never in the five years of UN peace-keeping in Tajikistan had they seen such a vicious attack against their colleagues. Similar cases can hardly be found in the entire history of the United Nations. UNMOT immediately recalled all staff from team sites to Dushanbe and issued a Press Release condemning the "cold-blooded murder". The same day the whole UN system suspended all its programmes and activities in the whole region of the incident.

Major Ryszard Szewczyk, Polish and 50 years old, was a very dynamic, highly balanced and extraordinary officer who demonstrated an excellent performance as a Military Observer at UNMOT. He was highly intelligent, hard working and a dutiful officer who was devoted to the cause of peace. As a team leader he successfully led his team to a number of challenging and difficult tasks and exhibited outstanding performance. He conducted numerous patrols and showed courage and high standards of morale. His devotion to duty was beyond question. At the same time he was kind and considerate to the local population at all team sites where he implemented the UN mandate for peace-keeping. Before UNMOT he had served at UNPROFOR and UNAVEM. The last memory we have of him is when he tried so hard to get a sick Tajik man on a UN helicopter to save his life and while this is difficult at UN, he finally succeeded to save the man. Such was his devotion to life. He was married with one child.

Major Adolfo Scharpegge was from Uruguay and 38 years old. He had only joined UNMOT three weeks before his tragic death. He was a highly intelligent and balanced officer who did extraordinarily well during his short span of service. He was hard working, enthusiastic and dutiful. Major Scharpegge looked to his duties with enthusiasm and full professionalism. He liked to accomplish the most challenging tasks and displayed the same with extraordinary performance. He was married with one child.

Mr Yutaka Akino was 48 and from Japan. He had a Doctorate in Law from Hokkaido University in Japan. He had been at UNMOT for about four months prior to his tragic death. He was a top scholar in history of International Relations specializing on Eurasia. He is well known in Japan as an expert on Central Asia and specially on Tajikistan. He has a number of publications mainly on Russian policy towards her south. During his short stay at UNMOT he proved that he had a brilliant mind and an unquenchable thirst for gathering information and researching into the socio-political conditions of Tajikistan. He was bright and dynamic and made many close friends amongst the Tajiks in all the areas he was so keen to travel to. Other than Japanese, he spoke fluent English and Russian and had a full working knowledge of Czech with some knowledge of Polish, French and Chinese. He was married with two children.

Jourajon Mahramov was from Tajikistan and 47 years old. He was the longest serving interpreter at UNMOT. Many MILOBS made the comment that when Jourajon accompanied them on an observation patrol not only was he an excellent interpreter but he also gave them a lot of information about life in Tajikistan and Tajik customs and social ethics. Before joining UNMOT, he was for a long time a Senior Research Assistant at the Institute of World Economy and International Relations. He came from the area where he was killed [Garm] and he taught at various schools in that area for several years before moving to Dushanbe. He was married with three children.

 

 

On Tuesday 21 July, the Secretary-General of the United Nations, Mr Kofi Annan, and members of the Security Council condemned the murders of four staff members of the United Nations Mission of Observers in Tajikistan. The statement

read to reporters said the Secretary-General "condemns in the strongest terms this act of cold-blooded murder." Mr Annan called upon the government of Tajikistan and the United Tajik Opposition "to make every effort to bring to justice those responsible for this heinous act." The Security Council President, Sergey Larov, of the Russian Federation said the Security Council members also called on the Government of Tajikistan to finalize their investigation "as soon as possible".

First thing on Wednesday morning, 22 July, the SRSG, Mr Jan Kubiš, met President Imomali Rahmanov to discuss the gravity of the situation for the United Nations Mission of Observers to Tajikistan. In the meeting the President expressed his grief about the killings and assured the SRSG that a special commission shall be set up promptly to investigate the murders and bring to justice the instigators of the crime. SRSG stressed in that meeting that concrete results were essential if the UN’s mandate in Tajikistan was to continue as before.

Immediately after his meeting with the President, the SRSG held a Press Conference in Dushanbe in which he referred to the "tragedy" as being in his opinion " unprecedented" in the annals of the United Nations. He said the UN had lost four of its members when "they were performing their duties, their mandate, working with full responsibility, supporting peace and stability in this country". The SRSG asserted that these men were killed when they had been fully assured, by those who could give these assurances, of creating conditions for their safe work. He said that "one would expect that under such circumstances, with a clear mandate to assist the country and the people of Tajikistan, that they should be welcomed and greeted by everyone". But, he added, that did not turn out to be the case. Instead, "UN staff were brought out of their car and shot on the spot". This, the SRSG said, cannot be described as anything other than cold-blooded murder.

The SRSG was asked by reporters about the reaction of the President since he’d just returned from meeting him. He said that the President had offered his deepest condolences and assured him that the perpetrators will be punished. The SRSG also informed journalists that all Military Observers and civilian staff had been recalled from their team sites in various parts of Tajikistan and that they would all be back in Dushanbe by the same evening. In response to questions from reporters as to whether other measures were likely by the UN, Mr Kubiš said that other measures were being discussed in consultation with New York. He clarified that any such measures will only be taken after the results of investigations became public.

The same day, the SRSG met members of the international community, other UN agencies as well as international organisations and NGOs operating in Tajikistan, to inform them of the details of the tragedy and discuss security measures required in the event of MILOBs being recalled to Dushanbe. He later met the Ambassadors of all missions in Tajikistan.

In the afternoon of the same day, the SRSG met the First Deputy Prime Minister and a leading member of the UTO, Mr Tourajanzoda to express his position concerning the killings. Mr Tourajanzoda described the incident as being shameful for Tajikistan and said he will do all in his power to help in the investigation.

The President and the UTO React

Ñ Later on the same day, 22 July, in a letter of condolence to the United Nations Secretary General, Mr Kofi Annan, President Rahmanov said he was deeply shocked by the tragic death of UNMOT staff which "deeply hurt Tajik people". He added that it was difficult to accept "the loss of brave and honorable" people who despite difficulties of their mission served the noble goal of reaching national reconciliation. He said UNMOT has been making an invaluable contribution to the peace process in Tajikistan, and its members are treated "with the highest respect and gratitude in Tajikistan". He stressed "this heinous crime" was committed by those who are against peace in Tajikistan and the people of Tajikistan share the grief and suffering of the relatives of the deceased and convey their condolences. The President assured Mr Annan that a Joint Commission was to be set up to investigate the crime and that additional measures would be undertaken to assure the security of representatives of the international organizations working in Tajikistan so that any such act "would be prevented in the future".

In the evening, 22 July, it was announced on Tajik State TV that in a special decree the President had ordered a Joint Commission to investigate the crime. The Commission was to be made up of Government and UTO members with UNMOT acting as an observer. According to a Presidential Decree the JC was to be headed by the Deputy prime Minister, Abdorahman Azimov. The President also signed a decree for the setting up of a Permanent Committee responsible for the security of foreign nationals. In an emergency meeting of Tajikistan’s National Security Council, Presidnet Rahmanov repremanded the Deputy Prime Minister, Abdorahman Azimov, and the Defence Minister, Shirali Kheiruliev, for serious security lapses. He also sacked the First Deputy Defence Minister, Abullo Habibov, and the Deputy Defence Minister, Sadeq Babajanov.

Ñ For their part, the UTO leadership strongly condemned the killing and described it as shameful for Tajikistan.

The UTO also issued a press statement explaining that the victims had passed the UTO check point at 1400 on the day the crime was committed. They explained that in their estimation the murders had taken place 12 km passed their check point and 2.5 km before the government check point before Labi Jar. The UTO described the incident as a "terrorist" action "committed by enemies of peace and stability". They offered their deepest condolences to the family and relations of the victims as well as to the United Nations and its representatives in Tajikistan. In a message from Teheran, the UTO leader, Said Abdullo Nuri, condemned the killings and said that he had asked all field commanders to do all they could to help the investigations. Fourteen UTO field commanders, including Mirzo Zioev, Mahmadrouzi, and Mullo Abdullo also issued a statement on 24 July expressing anger at the killings. They appealed to the Government, the CNR and the Contact Group to set up a competent commission for investigating the crime.

Ñ The Chairman of Garm Hukumat, Mr Abdudjabborov, and the Commander of UTO forces in Garm, General

Nizomov, sent a letter of condolence addressed to the UN Secretary-General, Mr Annan, to the SRSG, and to UNMOT’s Chief Military Observer, General Ariffin, expressing the sorrow of the population, the local authorities and Mujaheddin of the Garm District at losing "these heros of struggle for stability in the long-suffering country of Tajikistan". The letter said that the population of Garm will never forget the murdered persons and their noble service.

On the morning of Thursday 23 July the SRSG went to give his personal condolences to the family of Mr Jorajon Mahramov in their residence. Jorajon’s wife, son, daughter as well as his brother received the SRSG and express their deep sorrow and grief. The SRSG said he fully shared their grief and added that the United Nations was ready to help in anyway it could to ease the burden of pain that they must be feeling. He explained the conditions and while praising Mr Mahramov as the longest serving local staff and an excellent interpretor, he said the UN will do all in its power to bring the instigators of this crime to justice. The previous day an official UNMOT delegation comprising military and civilian members took part in the remembrance and burial ceremony of their loved colleague, Jorajon Mahramov.

t Contact Group Condemns the Brutal Murders

Members of the Contact Group met on July 23 and strongly condemned what they described as the organisers and perpetrators of this ruthless crime and asked the Government of Tajikistan and the UTO to make immediate efforts to

identify the murderers. Their Press Release was published the following day.

 

 

A special United Nations ceremony was held on Friday 24 July at UNMOT’s headquarters in Dushanbe to honor men who had, with the most dignified human values, given their lives for the cause of peace in a foreign land miles away from their family and loved ones. In the ceremony -- attended by all UN staff in Dushanbe as well as delegations from the countries of the deceased and friends from the international community and Tajik society -- the SRSG said a last farewell on behalf of all UNMOT members to our loved colleagues. In his remembrance speech the SRSG said every single one of the men who lost their lives was unique; yet they shared many similar qualities: "they all gave their lives to save other people’s lives". He said the United Nations stands and falls with people like them, people with such undivided devotion to the cause of peace, to creation of stability and democracy around the world. He added that the UN shall honor their memory and their courage in accepting their duties and going without arms into areas where hundreds and possibly thousand other men were armed. The SRSG proceeded by decorating the coffins of the deceased -- laid in the front courtyard of UNMOT -- with a United Nations Medal of Honor. Then, in a long procession of over fifty UN vehicles, more than four hundred people who had attended the ceremony accompanied the coffins to Dushanbe Airport from where the bodies were sent in a UN airplane to their countries of origin: Poland, Uruguay and Japan. Along the route many Tajiks stood to pay their last respects.

UNMOT NEWSLETTER 22 JULY-3 AUGUST 1998, No.22

Letters, faxes, telegrams and messages of condolence poured into UNMOT from all over the world. Statements condemning the crime were also published by foreign ministries of most countries around the world. UNMOT issued a Public Statement thanking eveyone for sharing its grief.